(443) 716-4400

The dramatic photo of a fishing vessel perched atop a sailboat that’s circulated widely online isn’t AI-generated—it captures a real collision that occurred on the Chesapeake Bay in 2018. While the image is striking, it also highlights important legal and navigational lessons for all boaters, from weekend sailors to professional captains.

In a recent episode of From the Wheelhouse, maritime attorney Todd Lochner joins Capt. John Martino and Capt. Matt Benhof to discuss the incident—how it unfolded, what the official investigation revealed, and what it teaches us about maritime liability law.

Watch the Full Podcast Episode

Watch the full podcast episode here:


The Incident That Shocked the Boating Community

On a calm August day in 2018, a charter fishing boat collided with a J/105 sailboat named Levitation, resulting in one of the most jaw-dropping images in boating history: the fishing vessel came to rest balanced on top of the sailboat’s cockpit.

Although some online viewers questioned its authenticity, the photo is real—and thanks to analysis from Lochner and a detailed recreation by the Annapolis School of Seamanship, we now have a clearer understanding of how this unusual incident happened.

What the Collision Teaches Us: Navigation and Legal Liability

During the discussion, Lochner breaks down:

  • Which vessel had the right of way under the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea (COLREGS)
  • How liability is assigned in multi-vessel accidents involving both recreational and commercial craft
  • The importance of crew behavior, speed, and maintaining a proper lookout
  • How reenactments can play a role in clarifying complex or disputed scenarios

As Lochner notes, understanding and applying the “rules of the road” in real-time situations is critical—not just for safety, but also for legal protection.

Recreating the Collision: Seamanship Meets Analysis

The Annapolis School of Seamanship reconstructed the event using trained instructors and real boats. The result confirmed that, while visually improbable, the scenario was physically possible.

In the podcast, they discuss the importance of recognizing Constant Bearing Decreasing Range (CBDR) and the challenges involved in recreating the collision course.

What the Coast Guard Found

The official Coast Guard report provides further insight into the collision, including environmental conditions, vessel operations, and final conclusions. While much of this is covered in the podcast, the report itself offers valuable context.

To make it easier for readers to explore further, we’ve prepared a summary of the most relevant findings—available through our Client Resource Library.

Click here to read Coast Guard report

Key Legal Takeaways for Boaters

Whether you’re operating a fishing vessel, charter yacht, or recreational sailboat, this case underscores the following:

  • Collisions can result in liability—even without intentional misconduct.
  • Clear documentation, communication, and crew training are essential safeguards.
  • Being proactive about legal and regulatory knowledge can significantly reduce risk.
  • If you’re involved in a maritime incident, working with an experienced admiralty attorney is essential.

Need Help After a Boating Accident?

Attorney Todd Lochner has decades of experience representing clients in complex maritime cases. Whether you’re a boat owner or a passenger, the right legal support can make all the difference.Call us today at (443) 716-4400 to schedule a consultation.